Check the archives, but yes, I recall some people having the same issues with the BAT bar as the Aussie bar wrt subframe/bracket failure. The great TH suggested to me that I consider reinforcement regardless of what bar I chose.
As for the diameter, check the archives again, but I think the BAT bar was something like 20.4 mm. The stock "19mm" bar is actually 18.x. To confuse matters even more, the early SE "19mm" bar and the later SVT "18mm" bar are, IIRC, exactly the same.