Wow, thats a pretty wide range of cars....
My suggestion is the Acura 3.2CL-S... good reliability, good power, comes with a 6 speed, and the resale is crap so you can pick up a used one cheap as hell. Its the most luxurious car of the list, and insurance will probably be cheaper than a lot of those other ones.
That's what i think if that's gonna be your only car... if you're going to keep the accord as a daily beater, i would recommend the S2000, or a 00-01 Audi TT Roadster... some damn good deals can be found on those (i'm looking for one myself

)