When I first started dating Mike, I noticed a lot of weird furniture coincidences.
I noticed he and his brother had the same bunk beds that my brothers had growing up (he and his brother used them as twin beds separately by then). The bunkbeds were rare to begin with. They looked handmade, so I was surprised to see someone else with the same exact set.
He and I also had the same exact alarm clock, which we both owned since junior high school.
He had the same clothes dresser from when he was a baby - it's the same one my brothers and I had when we were babies and my brother still uses it. Mike's is at our house now.
They also owned the same exact crib that my brothers and I grew up with. It was not a matching set to the clothes dresser, which is even more bizarre.
Our paths also crossed multiple times before we officially met (which is even more of a stupid/unlikely story). He lived 2 towns over, but attended the same church I did a couple times. He also attended all of his high school football games, including the ones against my high school - and I attended all of our home games.