Don't go with either of those cards, but do stick with nVidia, an FX5200 like someone said will only set you back 60-70ish

this card:

http://www.gainwardusa.com/products/vga_p660tv.htm

Gainward 5200 w/ low profile adapter!

Only 67.95 at my local computer store http://www.computersonics.com
They would ship to you if you are interested, though they often run out of merchandise and don't update the site.. so it might be best to call ahead

I'm sure you can find that model at a larger 'computer shop' in your area.. Maybe not at CompUSA/Circuit City/Best Buy though

Hope that helps

T-Red 1998.5 Contour SVT Mods: Foglight 'hack' Manual Antenna switch (Thanks for the idea Ryan Wood) 20% tint all around