Jabberjack Well to me water pump failure and belt failure can have same effect; overheating engine that should not be driven. Or at least only in short bursts after cool down. An idiot light, in addition to guage is definitely the better way to go. I have a '90 Buick Century that has both.
Re the cone: intact and in place. A few scuff marks, no dents. I would bet impeller shattering damages cone in most cases.
Regards.
p.s. I still have the '98 with 60,000 miles as a possible candidate for pre-emptive metal pump, but at the moment I don't want to see another wp for a while.
