my car only sees Bernie's Custom Paint in Olympia (20 minutes south of Tacoma). They do excellent work, and they are on Allstate's list of regulars. They are not listed as a 'preferred partner' because they charge a hefty fee, but if you're just paying the deductible...
Here's what my door repair looks like...
http://home.attbi.com/~sadeeq/Simmons_ONLINE_Photo_Album/SVT_Repairs/FrameSet.htm