Forget the Goodyear Eagle GA. Everything I've ever seen about these tires says they're mediocre, even though your mileage has been good.
Look at the new Dunlop SP Sport A2. It's a high performance all-season tire that, according to Tire Rack, ranks a little ahead of the Bridgestone 950. Beware of occasional quality problems on the Bridgestone; read the customer Reviews at Tire Rack for both the 950s and the SP Sport.
Whether either tire has been around long enough to get a good idea of snow performance is another question. Keep watching the Tire Rack customer Reviews if you can, or post Luke, he may have an answer.
Between the Dunlop and Bridgestone, you're bound to find something better than almost anything Goodyear makes.
