So they should have offered you new lugs. That's odd. I got my Konigs from them "cough"before JVT"cough"

and I knew from the getgo I'd need new lugs. Got some smaller spline lock lugs for $16.00 for all four rims.

All of them are locks and look great to boot. I'd talk with someone else and BAT would not sell them if they wouldn't fit. IMHO
John