I have ordered new metal Tredex pump via East End Automotive Distributors should arrive in pm tomorrow. Weather was not conducive to outdoor work today so no real loss to wait one more day.
Fenco tan plastic reman pump returned to Crappy Tire.
Edit @2:15pm May 14/02:
Pump arrived at noon today, curious the casting, shaft and pulley are stamped GMB Japan. Cost was $126 Cdn + tax (no casting charge since it's new, not reman). I won't lengthen post by reciting details but the telephone customer service at this "cubby hole of a store front" was amazing. I'll be back.
The reman Fenco pump at Canadian Tire was $95 Cdn BTW. (East End said $65 for Fenco plastic one)
I did by the way MartinS follow up NAPA store in Pickering. They did not have a pump in stock yesterday and did not know if they were plastic or metal. However, the parts guy said they needed one for stock anyway and would order in and I could come in and look at on Tues. I did and it had a white impeller, packaged in their housebrand box, although he said it was reman by Fenco. Cost was $105 Cdn but I said I had already ordered a metal one. He said I could have it for $92, I said thanks anyways. He did indicate he could also order metal one.
Edit: See later post for East End location.