I believe it is the one in the October MT.
If i were to buy, I think I would go with the G35 based on price alone.
If money weren't a factor I would probably go for the BMW. However the BMW name alone carries a lot of connotations, some that aren't positive about a persons character.
I think they are a tie honestly, however I don't think the BMW should win, when it costs as much as it does over the G35.