Oh holy crap!!!!
That's a HUGE difference! I'd keep the seats (they're just SOOOOO sweet, and that really is a beautiful tan color), and go with a nice saddle-leather brown to contrast with the seats. Cover the door inserts in a seat-matching leather. Mmmmmm.....
Sorry, my photoshopping abilities rival my Halo 2 online abilities. That is to say....they suck!
Saddle leather:
I think it makes a HOTTTTTTT combo!
