The Jaguar's one area of superiority is, naturally, handling. But it ranks behind most of the others in braking (though
all were good in this area), noise, interior room in general, the rear seat in particular, trunk space, fit and finish,
mileage, and price. And as far as reliability goes, early signs are not promising. Overall, "It lacks the refinement of
a $40,000 car."
This is probably about right. Sweet handling, small interior & expensive. Most other sources suggest fit & finish is good but may be car to car variation. They left out Jag style and elegance though - hard to match with a Lexus.
Consumer reports is OK, but remember it is aimed at "typical" consumers not gear heads. Your mom would find CR evalations right on the money. It is not "Enthusiests Reports".
