I purchased the tires from Tire Kingdom and they are the ones that had no clue what could be wrong. This whole thing took about a month to resolve.
When they couldn't figure it out they said I could take the car to Good Year and have them force balance the tires since Tire Kingdom doesn't have that capability. Tire Kingdom reimbursed me.
Anyways, when the car was done the mechanics at Good Year said 3 out of four tires were warped. The tires are Good Year Triple-Treads. They are slightly larger than OEM. Maybe that could be part of the issue.
Thanks for the input - just didn't want to go too long with something that could be damaging.
For all I know they messed something up when lifting the car. I've already had that happen twice. Someone either lifts the car up by the body kit or puts the lifter on the unprotected undeside of the car. I don't understand how anyone can mess that up!
Thanks all!