it depends on what you really really want.. Iike me I'm tired of going to the gas station and crying, repainting the car after always getting hit, and not having any room to haul stuff..
My next car is definately going to be a Matrix/Vibe..
48mpg on highway and you can fit 3 mountain bikes inside it..
All plastic bumpers so you don't have to repaint every year..
My dad owns a 2004 Gray Pontiac Vibe.. it is by far the best car we've ever owned, great quality Toyota parts and we get close to 36-40mpg on it..
but once again its up to what you really really want.. a great Tour replacement plus great looking car is a TSX... mmm TSX goodness..
cheers
Martin