Originally posted by GTO Pete:
A few QBs in the last 15 years worth nothing:

Dan Marino
John Elway
Brett Favre
Steve Young
Jim Kelly
Troy Aikman
Kurt Warner
Peyton Manning
Donavan McNabb
Warren Moon

I would take any of those QBs in their prime over Brady. Easily.

(And Brady doesn't even make my top 25 QBs of all-time.)


IMO using Super Bowl rings as the measuring stick for being the "best" QB is ludicrous. You would exclude some of the greatest QBs in NFL history.



Are you kidding me, look at this story, and this was written 12 months ago.
http://64.91.242.40/Article.php?Page=120

How can you say a QB that has one over 70% of his games, has never, NEVER lost a post season game, has never, NEVER lost a game with the temp below 40. He also has (I think) the most 4th quarter comebacks in the NFL.

And yes rings do matter, that's what the whole purpose of the season is. What's the use of throwing for 10,000 yards and 70 touchdowns if you never win a ring. Brady already has more than Manning will have in his career. And Brady is only 28. He will probably have like 6-7 by the time he is done.

I would take Brady over Manning any day. Dare tell me something that Manning does better than Brady (and no, losing big games does not count).

Bill Jenkins Team Ford, Internet Parts Dept. 5445 Drexel Rd. Las Vegas, NV 89130 CLICK HERE to order parts Ford parts at wholesale prices