Well, I peeled the chrome and rubber surround off and painted the insert black. The car is white so the contrast looks pretty good and I'm not a fan of chrome anyways.
I scuffed it with sand paper, put a coat of primer, sprayed it with satin black, and then put a coat of clear on it. Clear was just so wax doesn't stick to it. Looks pretty good. Only time will tell how long it will last
