If you are saying that one of the rotors has deep score marks then it most certainly beyond saving by machining.
I personally have had good luck with Raybestos rotors in the past with many different cars. I would avoid the Raymold rotors though unless price is critical and you would not be keeping the car. Bendix makes excellent rotors. In my mind it would be a toss up between Raybestos and Bendix with Bendix having a very slight edge. I'm not familiar with Rabestos -- Amico. Amico, as far as I know, is still a different brand. I suspect that the parts store changed over from Amico to Raybestos and that they have been relabeled to show the Raybestos part number to make it easier to keep track of the inventory. Overall, I don't have a favorable impression about Amico, but no hard fast facts to back it up.
