Definitely shop for insurance. That's huge! I have an interesting driving record that includes an SR-22 filing...and I pay $167 a month!
Are you or any of your family affiliated with the government in any way? If so check out USAA. They have the best rate in America.
Otherwise it's a crap shoot. Just call around. Several companies offer online quotes. That's a good deal, but stay away from companies you've never heard of offering to find you the best quote. There are scammers out there!
Good Luck
Mike (sick as a dog, sorry if I ramble)