Originally posted by RTStabler51:
Why'd you have to drag my Giants into this? We have a Manning. And his ass should be riding the pine. I wouldn't say the Giants recievers suck. They are average, maybe a tad above average. When Kurt Warner or Kerry Collins were behind the center Amani and Ike had pretty good years. You put Eli back there, and now its the recievers faults? Eli sucks and should be riding hte pine for 2 years or so....c'mon tom!

...now back to the topic.
Originally posted by Kokopellian:
Look at the NY giants. Their receivers suck. You could put manning on that team and he wouldn't be half as good because their receivers can't catch. Bottom line is Favre has proven his greatness, manning is still in the process but when all is said and done we are looking at 2 of the greatest QB's of their time





Hilliard and toomer are 2 of the most overrated recievers ever. Hilliard had a couple of good years and then [censored] the bed. They are great when they catch the ball but they flat out have awful hands. Ron Dixon is even worse.