So, he plays on a team with poor defense, doesn't diminish his abilities. The thing that bothers me about Favre is he doens't know when to sit. There have been a couple of years where the team would have been bettered served if he had sat out 5-6 games, yet he continued to play and caused the team to lose by playing with injuries. I admire his toughness, but it can go to far. All that said, Peyton is doing things that others simply aren't capable of including Farve. He can throw it deep with accuracy, he has touch when needed, he has an absolute canon when the time calls for it, and not only does he look off defensive backs, he literally knows where every receiver is without looking. If he doesn't win a superbowl it will be a shame, but if he doesn't he will simply displace Marino as the best pure passer in NFL history. I guess I should be following Tom Brady, he is obviously twice as good as Favre.
