According to my CEL codes, both my right side and left side precats have been bad for the last 30,000 miles, and so far, I haven't seen any difference in drivability, power, or mileage. I'm still consistently averaging 30 mpg. The dealer's service department even agreed that spending the $3500 or so to replace the cats wouldn't make the car run any differently than it does now. We don't have emissions testing in Kansas, so that isn't an issue.