Originally posted by whateverdude:
Does that mean there is a design flaw in the car?
I don't know if I would call it a "design flaw", after all cars don't last forever, but it is a fairly common problem for our cars. I would think that it would fall under the "normal wear and tear" category.
I rarely hear other cars having similar problems with the EGR. Does ford/mercury warranty this flaw to a certain extent?
If you are within warranty, then Ford might take care of it, but I'm not sure. Someone else on the boards might know better.
If your out of warranty, then definitely not, unless you recently had the EGR system worked on and the same piece broke again.
So what is a fair cost for a shop to diagnostic the problem and fix it?
Don't have any idea. I don't work in the business, but here is my guesstimate...
If you decided to replace ALL of the major parts (EGR, EVR, DPFE) to the EGR system, then you should be able to buy the parts brand new for around $150. It would take me a few hours to do the labor (and I'm not a professional and don't have power tools). Let's say 3-4 hours on the long side. At $75/hr. (it might be more or less in your area), you would have $300 in labor at the most. Thus, it would cost about $450 for the whole thing.
But the problem is that it might be something else, like the EGR vacuum hoses or the EGR-to-exhaust manifold pipe or even the PCM.
Most of the work is not that difficult to do yourself, it just depends on your ability and your confidence level. You will also need to spend some $ on tools if you don't have them.
Other than that, all I can say is to take the car to a few auto repair shops and get an estimate. Once you get an estimate, post another message with the cost and what they say they will do and you should get at least a few opinions.