for a 95 like you describe... lots of people try to sell it for $5000 plus. Last summer, I bought my 95 SE (loaded, leather, excellent shape) for $4500 with 113k on it, and it was a steal. You should be able to sell it for around that, because dealers will do a trade in value for about $3000 to $3500, and then try to sell it for like $6000. IMO, you should put an ad in the paper for $4500, max $5000. But it all depends on the condition of the car, and the options that it has.
