Originally posted by Big Jim:
The rotor (other than the friction face) will look better longer if you have it plated. It will not rust nearly as soon. I think it is worth it. Some, however, believe that you would be just as well of to paint the rotor with some high temp paint.
Well, I used the hi-temp on my new rotors, and it is a cheaper option, but somewhat of a pain in the butt. I'm not really happy with the rears as I tried to mask off a swath where the pads would make contact. Since I had to change the rear pads right away, I didn't really have a choice. Anyway, it's next to impossible to keep this looking good, as it's too hard to get the masking just right.
My plan for the fronts is to put another coat of paint on them, and use the old pads to burnish/condition the rotors before I put the new pads on. I hope that works better.