Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
#279020 05/27/01 05:03 AM
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 15
M
MiSVT Offline OP
Junior Member
OP Offline
Junior Member
M
Joined: May 2001
Posts: 15
What are the pros/cons of doing a 'plus 1' and going to 17' wheels and tires? If the tires are the same width, what are the advantages? Which one weighs less (for comparable wheels and same brand tire)?


2000 Black and Tan CSVT
Built 1/27/00, #1929 of 2150
Mods: K&N Drop In
Coming Soon:
New Stereo, Bassani Cat Back, B&M
#279021 05/27/01 04:48 PM
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 1,861
B
Member
Offline
Member
B
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 1,861
I'm sure that others will comment as well.

One of the big advantages of larger wheels with the same overall tire diameter is better steering response. Since less of that total diameter is made up of tire, there is less tire flex and that makes for better response. It also makes for a firmer ride.

One of the problems with going to larger wheels with the same overall tire diameter is that because there is now less tire in the overall diameter, the wheel is more suseptable to damage from pot holes and such. My experience has been that you are usually pretty safe with 45 aspect ratio tires and are much more likely to have wheel problems with 40 aspect and smaller tires.

Life is like that most of the time. There are trade offs and you must decide which is best for you.


Jim Johnson
98 SVT
#279022 05/28/01 06:06 AM
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 770
T
Member
Offline
Member
T
Joined: May 2000
Posts: 770
PROS

* Shorter, stiffer sidewalls flex less under
hard cornering, improving response and driver
communication.

* 17" wheels tend to be either 7" or 7.5" in
width for our cars, which keeps the tire flat
on wheel, stabilizing the contact patch and
putting more of the tire on the road surface
for improved traction... even if the tire is
the same section width.

* Less sidewall flex and "roll-over" means a
high-speed drift or slide isn't sullied by a
skidding, chattering, stuttering, lumpy, fat
sidewall flopping around under the vehicle.

* Generally speaking, and using only the most
considered, technical wording here, plus-size
wheels and low-profile rubber have the effect
of appearing "bad ass" or "damn sweet" to the
trained observer. smile

CONS:

* Inexpensive cast wheels are usually heavier
than the factory alloys, which can increase
unsprung weight and *potentially* negatively
impact acceleration, suspension damping, and
braking.

* Reduced sidewall height means that even low
curbs can cause damage to the wheel surface.

* Reduced sidewall height means that potholes
and road obstacles may impact, bend, or crack
the wheel itself.

* Low-profile tires tend to be more sensitive
to tire pressure, and may need to be baby-sat
and monitored more closely.

* Even with lighter wheels, it is possible to
move unsprung weight further from the hub and
increase the "moment of inertia", which again
negatively affects acceleration and braking.

* Some loss in ride quality with low profile
tires judging with the same tire on different
sized wheels.

VERDICT:

This is your prototypical compromise when it
comes to performance. There is a reason that
you see 16" wheels on BMWs and Mercedes, but
there's equally valid reasons you'll see 17"
and 18" wheels too... it's about priorities.

T.


Moderated by  1314_dup1 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5