|
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 153
Member
|
Member
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 153 |
torsional damper != harmonic balancer :rolleyes:
no harmonic balancer == kaboom very quickly
no TVD =? lower reliabilty maybe
46,000 miles and counting on my UR UDP (like 2.5 - 3 years)
the NECO guy reported scored cams as well, hard to think an UDP would stop oil from reaching your top end.
97 SE MTX, KKM, UR UDP, 19# Injectors, SVT TB, SVT UIM, SVT Flywheel, Grizzly Street Clutch, Upgraded motor mounts, mystifed precats, brand new main cat, SVT exhaust sans resonator, 205-55-15 Dunlop SP5000's 154hp / 156 tq before the SVT exhaust, SVT dual honed upper and swapping the mystery main cat for mystery precats. My Profile
|
|
|
|
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 878
Member
|
Member
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 878 |
OK, different car, different engine, but the Saturn guys at SC Racing took the whole darn belt off for their first dyno run and gained a whopping 3hp. They figured the best they could do was about a 20% underdrive for a whopping gain of .6 hp on something that is probably detrimental to engine life over the long haul. Even if it isn't, it's hardly worth the money.
In their words, "In racing, horsepower talks and marketing bull$hit walks."
"Function before fashion."
'96 Contour SE
|
|
|
|
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 153
Member
|
Member
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 153 |
Originally posted by RogerB: OK, different car, different engine, but the Saturn guys at SC Racing took the whole darn belt off for their first dyno run and gained a whopping 3hp. They figured the best they could do was about a 20% underdrive for a whopping gain of .6 hp on something that is probably detrimental to engine life over the long haul. Even if it isn't, it's hardly worth the money.
In their words, "In racing, horsepower talks and marketing bull$hit walks." Yes, but they still had the heavy weight of the pulley on there. Yes the pulley radius is smaller than a flywheel, but there is still a 5 lb chunk of steel at like 4 inches off axis of rotation. That is roughly equivalent to taking 1-2 lbs off of an 8 inch radius flywheel.
97 SE MTX, KKM, UR UDP, 19# Injectors, SVT TB, SVT UIM, SVT Flywheel, Grizzly Street Clutch, Upgraded motor mounts, mystifed precats, brand new main cat, SVT exhaust sans resonator, 205-55-15 Dunlop SP5000's 154hp / 156 tq before the SVT exhaust, SVT dual honed upper and swapping the mystery main cat for mystery precats. My Profile
|
|
|
|
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 422
Member
|
Member
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 422 |
the NECO guy reported scored cams as well, hard to think an UDP would stop oil from reaching your top end. It could if bits of bearing material clog the oil passages...
2000 Mercury Cougar V6 ATX. 16.0@87MPH, 155.0 FWHP
|
|
|
|
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 4,527
Administrator
|
Administrator
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 4,527 |
I would like the name of the person you spoke w/ at SVT.
It's all about balance.
bcphillips@peoplepc.com
|
|
|
|
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 620
Member
|
Member
Joined: Apr 2001
Posts: 620 |
I can say i've met two people with U/D pulleys and have had no problems for over a year or two....
I'm not doing it but just bringing up a interesting point.
SVT EMBLEM MOD HERE :::96:C:LX:::Black 2.5L ATX "my beater" - Shaved ? badgeless ? SE rocker panels :::99:SVT:C::: #2566 of 2760 T-RED/TAN "the bitçh" Brullen Cat-back w/ 3.5" angle-cut tips ? BAT European Suspension ? AFE Filter ? CnL 73mm MAF ? Diablosport Chip :MNQ3: ? Mirko front spilter ? Apexi SAFC (i'm scared to install! anyone in Norcal wanna help me?) ..::nyceboicreations.com::.. email:junkmail@nyceboicreations.com
|
|
|
|
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 176
Member
|
Member
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 176 |
I think the point here isn't when it happens, just that it WILL happen. Do as you wish 
2000 Roush Cougar MTX MSDS Headers, Rear disc conversion, SVT TB and IM, Custom 2.5" exhaust, Weapon R Dragon w/kkm MAF adaptor, B&M, NR wht gauges
|
|
|
|
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 153
Member
|
Member
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 153 |
Originally posted by Frank: the NECO guy reported scored cams as well, hard to think an UDP would stop oil from reaching your top end. It could if bits of bearing material clog the oil passages...Yes it "could", but I know of a few people running top ends from fried 2.5's(spun bearings) on there 3.0's now. Most reported engine failures eat just the bearing, leaving most eveything else at least visually clean. With the number of duratecs biting it naturally (ie with stock pulleys - and remember for crank whip the stock unit is just as bad as an UDP) it's hard to statisticly say how much an UDP may shorten life expectancy. I suppose I could send my oil out for analysis by one of the labs to look for bearing material in it (similar to how aircarft predict time for complete overhauls).
97 SE MTX, KKM, UR UDP, 19# Injectors, SVT TB, SVT UIM, SVT Flywheel, Grizzly Street Clutch, Upgraded motor mounts, mystifed precats, brand new main cat, SVT exhaust sans resonator, 205-55-15 Dunlop SP5000's 154hp / 156 tq before the SVT exhaust, SVT dual honed upper and swapping the mystery main cat for mystery precats. My Profile
|
|
|
|
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 7,329
Member
|
Member
Joined: Sep 2000
Posts: 7,329 |
Originally posted by ScottK97SEMTX: the NECO guy reported scored cams as well, hard to think an UDP would stop oil from reaching your top end. Damaged main bearings = loss of oil pressure = loss of upper cylinder lubrication first = scored cams That is a perfect example of what crank whip can do.
|
|
|
|
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 24
Junior Member
|
Junior Member
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 24 |
Originally posted by Terry Haines: ALL the Duratec engines have harmonic balancers/dampers,2.5, 3.0 etc.. This is somewhat correct. The pulley can't be a 'harmonic balancer/damper' because it connects between two external systems (the crank and the accessory drive belt.) An harmonic damper would connect to an isolated ring of specific mass and size through a damping element. Changing the mass and shape of the ring or the shape and stiffness of the elastomer would change the tuning. HOWEVER, Terry is correct to warn you to proceed at your own risk. The pulley does act as a broad, untuned damped coupling and will damp transient vibrations at the snout of the crank. How much fatigue damage these transient vibrations might cause has never been admitted (officially) by Ford.
|
|
|
|
|