Originally posted by SVTatGT:
No, not particularly. However, that was honestly one of the worst analogies I have ever heard, and I particularly don't think you can actually think that was a good paralell. However, if you do believe that those two situations are simular, then we can debate the merits of that argument...


It wasn't an analogy. I was just saying, if it's so wonderful to be starved and dehydrated to death, then people should be upset if the pope doesn't get to live in that joy.

My point is that it's absurd to think that dehydration and starvation are pleasant situations.