Those are way to long, thats why it keeps splitting. The longest you will need is 1.25 to 1.5 inches. A brad gun works the best because you can put alot in and can see them.
That's what I used, 3/4" mdf with 1 1/4 brad nails, also applied tight bond 3 before nailing the mdf together, then used wood caulk on all the interior edges to seal them for sure...
Thats is the right way to do it, I hardly ever hear anyone using screws anymore. Wood glue, then nail, the would glue the seams and your done. At least thats the way I was taught at Mobile Dynamics in Pheonix.
Or instead of nails, get some proper wood clamps and do away with nails/screws completely. I can't remember the last time I used either on a project.
I think I may build another box this year and move from 10's to 12's, I gotta see if the trunk will have enough room to do that though...
Of course it will fit!